Skip to main content

Table 1 Next generation 16S rRNA gene amplicon based sequencing studies of the lower airway microbiome

From: The microbiome of the human lower airways: a next generation sequencing perspective

Referencea

Medical condition

n (cases + controls)

Lower respiratory tract sample type

Sequencing platform

Targeted 16S rRNA regions

Sequence analysis softwareb

[108]

arsenic exposure

10 + 10

sputum

IonTorrent

V6

QIIME

[91]

asthma

10 + 10

sputum

454

V6

RDP

[92]

asthma

39 + 12

BAL

454

V1V2

BARTAB, RDP

[56]

CF

23

sputum

454

V1V2

AbundantOTU, Lucy, mothur, RDP

[59]

CF

10

lung explant secretions, sputum

454

V1V3, V2V3

KrakenBLAST, QIIME

[57]

CF

17

sputum

454

V4V6

custom in-house pipeline

[60]

CF

25

sputum

454

V1V3

RDP

[58]

CF

23

sputum

454

V6V7

QIIME

[109]

CF

19 + 6

sputum, lung tissue

454

V4V5

Matlab, mothur, RDP

[110]

CF

21

sputum

454

V1V2

BARTAB, RDP

[111]

CF

30

sputum

454

V1V3

custom software, Kraken BLAST

[68]

COPD

11

sputum

MiSeq

V4

QIIME

[42]

COPD, smoking

19 + 3

BAL, lung tissue

454

V1V3

mothur, RDP

[66]

COPD, smoking

16 + 16

lung tissue

454

V1V3

mothur

[41]

healthy

6

BAL, lower airway protected brush

454

V1V2

QIIME

[49]

healthy

28

BAL

454

V3V5

mothur

[44]

healthy smokers

19 + 45

BAL

454

V1V3, V3V5

mothur

[52]

HIV

82 + 77

BAL

454

V1V3

QIIME

[107]

ILD

24 + 9

BAL

454

V3V5

PyroTagger

[6]

intubation

5

ETA

454

V1V3

MG-RAST, mothur

[104]

IPF

55

BAL

454

V3V5

mothur

[105]

IPF

65 + 44

BAL

454

V3V5

QIIME

[96]

lung transplantation

4 + 2

BAL

454

V3

mothur, RDP

[95]

lung transplantation

21

BAL

454

V1V2

QIIME

[12]

lung transplantation

33 + 26

BAL

454

V3V5

mothur

[97]

lung transplantation

57 + 8

BAL

454

V7V8

QIIME

[102]

non-CF bronchiectasis

41

BAL, sputum

454

V1V3

custom software, Kraken BLAST

[103]

non-CF bronchiectasis

42

sputum

454

V1V3

custom software, Kraken BLAST

[101]

non-CF bronchiectasis

40

sputum

454

V1V3

AbundantOTU, Lucy, mothur, RDP

[45]

smoking, pulmonary inflammation

20 + 9

BAL

454

V1V2

QIIME

[106]

tuberculosis

22 + 14

sputum

454

V1V2

QIIME

[43]

various

6

BAL

454

V1V2

QIIME

[112]

various

56 + 4

BAL, sputum

454

V1V3

mothur

  1. aIn the case of several publications using the same sequence data, only the first one is included
  2. bSoftware for diversity calculation, statistical comparisons etc. is not included. RDP refers to the standalone implementation. If RDP was used via mothur or QIIME, it is not listed
  3. Of special interest are the data on number of cases and controls, sample type, and 16S rRNA gene regions targeted for sequencing